SEED ORDERS SHIP IN 1-3 BUSINESS DAYS

Why You Should Grow Ugly Food: The Truth About Heirloom Tomatoes

If you walked into a grocery store and saw a tomato that was lumpy, misshapen, had cracks around the stem, and was a weird bruised-purple color, you would probably put it back.

We have been trained to think that a "good" tomato is perfectly round, uniformly red, and hard as a baseball.

But here is the truth that every seasoned gardener knows: The uglier the tomato, the better it tastes.

Those perfect red orbs at the supermarket? They are imposters. They were bred for one specific purpose: to survive a truck ride. They have thick skins to prevent bruising and low sugar content to prevent rotting. They are built for travel, not for taste.

Heirloom tomatoes, on the other hand, are divas. They are fragile, thin-skinned, and often look a little weird. But that "weirdness" is exactly why you should grow them.

Here is why you need some ugly food in your garden this year.

1. Thin Skins = Real Texture

Commercial tomatoes have skins like leather so they can stack in crates. Heirloom varieties like the Cherokee Purple or Black Krim have incredibly thin skins.

  • The "Flaw": They might crack if they get too much water, and they bruise easily.
  • The Reward: When you bite into them, the skin practically dissolves, giving you an immediate burst of juice and flesh. No chewing required.

2. "Catfacing" is a Badge of Honor

Ever see a giant heirloom tomato with deep folds, lumps, and scars on the bottom? Gardeners call this "catfacing."

  • The "Flaw": It looks messy and makes the tomato hard to slice perfectly evenly.
  • The Reward: Varieties that do this (like the massive Mortgage Lifter) are often the largest and most complex-tasting fruits in the garden. That weird shape is the result of a massive blossom trying to produce a massive fruit. It’s a sign of abundance, not failure.

3. Green Shoulders Mean Flavor

Many heirlooms keep a ring of green around the stem even when they are fully ripe.

  • The "Flaw": It looks unripe to the untrained eye.
  • The Reward: That "green shoulder" is often where the most intense, tangy flavor concentrates. It adds a complexity—a balance of acid and sugar—that a flat, red hybrid just can't match.

The "Ugly" Hall of Fame

Ready to embrace the imperfections? Here are three varieties that look strange but taste divine:

  • Cherokee Purple: Dark, dusky, and often misshapen, this is widely considered one of the best-tasting tomatoes on earth. It has a rich, smoky sweetness that is unmistakable.
  • Black Krim: A dark tomato from Ukraine that is prone to cracking, but offers a salty, savory flavor profile you can't find anywhere else.
  • Yellow Brandywine: It’s lumpy, it’s huge, and it’s a brilliant golden-orange. It tastes like pure fruit nectar.

The Verdict?

Stop growing tomatoes that look like plastic. Embrace the cracks, the lumps, and the weird colors. Because in the garden, beauty is skin deep, but flavor goes all the way to the core.

Find your perfect imperfect match: Shop our full collection of Heirloom Tomato Seeds and get ready for the best BLT of your life.

Back to News